FOOD NEWS
Ranking Unsalted Butter Brands From Worst To Best
BY NEALA BRODERICK
12. Breakstone's
Made of cream and natural flavors, Breakstone's unsalted butter isn't cheap. It costs around $4 per 8 ounces, but it’s mediocre with a pale color and mild flavor.
It has a natural saltiness and a tang, so it can be difficult to decipher whether it's salted or unsalted. It doesn't have many negative qualities, but nothing stands out either.
11. Land O'Lakes
Made of sweet cream and natural flavoring, Land O'Lakes unsalted butter doesn't have the tang of Breakstone's, which makes it a bit smoother on the palate.
This feature also makes the brand a better choice for general use. Its distinct buttery flavor feels nostalgic, probably a result of it being one of the most popular creameries.
10. Organic Valley
Organic Valley's unsalted butter is a pricey option at around $11 per pound and is impressive for its ultra-creaminess, but the flavor itself is somewhat muted.
The rich butter has that characteristic buttery feel and a creamy mouthfeel, but it lacks depth. Offering a bit more weight, it also has a thicker texture and heavier consistency.
9. Vital Farms
The cows at Vital Farms are pasture-raised and 90% grass-fed, and it really does seem to come through in every bite of the brand's unsalted butter.
Its earthiness is deliciously complex while still being silky smooth. The taste is delicate at first but has layers of flavors that deepen as the butter softens in your mouth.
8. Nellie's
Nellie's grass-fed unsalted butter is delicious. Slow-churned and made from pasteurized cream and lactic acid, it also has a slight hint of sweetness.
The sweetness balances well with the rich taste, making it decadent and fresh-tasting. It has a soft toast-spreading texture but also serves as a great fatty butter for baking.