Benchmark may be one of Buffalo Trace’s most underrated bourbons. It risks a popularity and price jump once word gets out how much it’s overlooked, so try to buy ASAP.

This family-owned distillery is passionate about what they do. A New Riff label that isn't even 10 years old yet is earning praise in the crowded world of Kentucky bourbon.

Maker's Mark is a highly popular wheat bourbon whisky, but it deserves more conscious appreciation. In fact, this company's entire line earns its own place on this list.

We love the complexity of a four-grain whiskey, and while double-oaked bottles are trendy, Penelope experiments with aging bourbon in wine casks for a more unique taste.